| Parents | 
| Husband | Male
 Jeremiah Wilcox FAY, (twin)
 
 | 
| Birth | 8 Mar 1822 | Parma, Cuyahoga, Ohio, USA  | 
| Died |  |  | 
| Buried |  |  | 
| Married | 5 Sep 1854 | Cleveland, Cuyahoga, Ohio  | 
| Father | Benajah FAY, Sr. | F1442 Group Sheet | 
| Mother | Ruth WILCOX | F1442 Group Sheet | 
| Wife | Female
 Mary Ann BRADLEY
 
 | 
| Birth | 5 Jul 1836 | Rockport, Cuyahoga, Ohio  | 
| Died | 1912 | Parma, Cuyahoga, Ohio,USA  | 
| Buried |  |  | 
| Father | Alfred BRADLEY | F1351 Group Sheet | 
| Mother | Clarissa BRISCOE | F1351 Group Sheet | 
|  | 
| Children | 
| Child 1 | Male
 > Alfred Wylie FAY
 
 | 
| Birth |  |  | 
| Died |  |  | 
| Buried |  |  | 
| Spouse | Jennie E. PECK | F1444 | 
| Married |  |  | 
| Child 2 | Male
 > Clarence E. FAY
 
 | 
| Birth | 1 Mar 1873 | Parma, Cuyahoga, Ohio, USA  | 
| Died | 24 Sep 1947 | Parma, Cuyahoga, Ohio, USA  | 
| Buried |  |  | 
| Spouse | Ruth R. STEVENS | F1443 | 
| Married |  |  | 
| Child 3 | Male
 William N. FAY
 
 | 
| Birth |  |  | 
| Died |  |  | 
| Buried |  |  | 
| Child 4 | Male
 Edgar B. FAY
 
 | 
| Birth |  |  | 
| Died |  |  | 
| Buried |  |  | 
| Spouse | Dora HOFFMAN | F26815 | 
| Married |  |  | 
| Child 5 | Male
 Albert W. FAY, [infant]
 
 | 
| Birth |  |  | 
| Died |  |  | 
| Buried |  |  | 
|  |